Anna Sui Mascara: Volume vs Lengthening

With some xmas vouchers i had received recently, i went to buy Anna Sui Mascara after testing out one sample :)

The SA introduced me to the lengthening one, which i got it in the end. The tester i had was "Volume up". Here is the comparison of them both! :)

Anna Sui Mascara

Anna Sui Lengthening

Anna Sui Volume

Lengthen

(see the fibres in and on the mascara wand, i wonder how long they can extend the lashes)

Volume

Lengthening

Smell: ♥♥♥♥♥ (rose fragrance)
Lengthens: yes
Volume: not so obvious
Waterproof : Nope
Easy dry?: need to wait awhile
Smudge: Slightly
Buy again? : Maybe no.

Volume

Smell: ♥♥♥♥♥ (rose fragrance)
Lengthens: no
Volume: not so obvious, makes my lashes look darker
Waterproof : Nope
Easy dry?: yes
Smudge: not really
Buy again? : Maybe no.

I only tried these two. I can't resist nice smelling products like Anna Sui's and Jill Stuart. And i always love japan cosmetics (although they are expensive!). For the only one which i had not try,  the purple wand of the Full version looks pretty, maybe i would get it if i get more vouchers :P